Wuthering Heights Casting Director Responds to Elordi Backlash

• Apr 29, 2025

Following the release of early set photos from the upcoming Wuthering Heights film, criticism over casting choices has intensified. Many viewers have voiced concerns that lead actors Jacob Elordi and Margot Robbie are not the right fit for their roles based on the characters’ descriptions in the original novel.

Both Jacob and Margot are Australian, and some fans believe their appearances and personas do not align with how Emily Brontë portrayed the characters in her 19th-century gothic romance. The backlash has sparked widespread discussion online, with readers and film enthusiasts debating whether the casting decisions respect the spirit of the novel.

Now, the film’s casting director has spoken out, addressing the concerns and defending the choices made for the project. Though specific quotes from the casting director were not shared, their response comes after weeks of online debate, which grew louder when photos emerged of Elordi and Robbie in costume on set.

The criticism centers mainly on whether the actors can convincingly portray the dark and complex nature of the story’s lead characters. Wuthering Heights is known for its intense emotional depth, and many fans feel that casting should reflect the tone and essence of the original work.

Despite the backlash, others have defended the casting, pointing out the talent and range of both Elordi and Robbie. Some argue that creative reinterpretation is a normal part of adapting classic literature for modern audiences, and that performance, not just appearance, should determine an actor’s suitability for a role.

The debate highlights a broader tension often seen when beloved novels are brought to the screen—especially when casting choices don’t match long-held reader expectations. While some fans appreciate bold and unexpected decisions, others feel strongly about staying faithful to the author’s original vision.

As filming continues, interest in the project remains high. Whether or not Jacob Elordi and Margot Robbie will ultimately win over skeptical fans may depend on the final result when the film is released. For now, the conversation around the casting choices shows no signs of slowing down.